Why is Gluten Only One of Six Unique Coexisting Physiological Changes Which are Required to Trigger Celiac Disease? Discovery of Celiac Disease Causes with a Novel Method of Finding Non Infectious Diseases Causes Which Combines Multiple Research

Authors

  • Alan Olan Independent Researcher, USA Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47363/JGHR/2026(7)196

Keywords:

Disease Causes, Celiac Disease, Non-Infectious Disease, Multiple Research, Frequency, Disease Causing Factor, Prevention, Root Cause, Disease Rate, Physiological Parameter, Method to Find a Cause

Abstract

Celiac disease (CD) is an inflammatory disorder of the upper small intestine triggered by the ingestion of wheat, rye, barley, and possibly oat products. The triggered immune reaction damages the intestinal mucosal layer and causes inflammation, which may result in a spectrum of gastrointestinal symptoms, such as diarrhea, fatigue, weight loss, bloating, etc. The global prevalence of biopsy confirmed CD has been 0.7%. The frequency of Celiac disease has increased in developed countries over the last decades and this finding points out the causal role of possible environmental triggers additional to gluten.


The clinical feature of CD is characterized by a small intestinal mucosa with the absence of normal villi, resulting in a generalized malabsorption of nutrients.CD arises in genetically susceptible individuals with HLA-DQ2 or HLA-DQ8 alleles and is characterized by a CD4+ T lymphocytes driven inflammation in the proximal small bowel triggered by gluten ingestion. Gluten is delivered to CD4+ T lymphocytes and activates them causing the secretion of different pro-inflammatory and inflammatory cytokines such as interferon (IFN)-γ, interleukins IL-1, IL-6, IL-8, IL-15 and others. After this, CD4+ T lymphocyte interaction with B lymphocytes leads to the release of autoantibodies such as anti-tissue transglutaminase (TTG) and DGA (deamidated gliadin antibody) which is a marker for active Celiac disease. The HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8 alleles encoded by approximately 30% of the general population. However, only approximately 1% of the population is diagnosed with Celiac disease which indicates additional factors may be involved in the progression of this complex disease. Also, while most individuals display improvement in Celiac symptoms and signs following institution of the gluten free diet, up to 30% continue to experience symptoms and/or have persisting intestinal inflammation. These individuals are classified as having non-responsive Celiac disease.
The first clear medical definition of Celiac disease was given by Samuel Gee in 1888. It has been almost 75 years since Dr. Willem-Karel Dicke and his colleguees identified gluten as the cause of the Celiac diseases symptoms in 1953. Since this time the only available treatment for Celiac disease continues to be a maintaining a strict gluten-free diet for life. This is despite the fact that approximately 17,806 studies related to Celiac Disease has been conducted until 2024 [1]. It seems a common sense that a new approach is required.


The goal of this study was to use a new approach based on a novel mathematically based method of finding non-infectious diseases cause and apply it to analyze the causes of Celiac disease.


This method has been published [3]. and also applied to other non-infectious diseases such as Breast Cancer, etc. and has shown results which are consistent with existing medical facts. The method is using a special algorithm based in math and allows to find disease causes for a specific non-infectious disease using results of multiple researches regarding risk factors of the disease.


The method is based on a model presented in the article “A Connection between Factors Causing Diseases and Diseases Frequencies: Its Application in Finding Disease Causes” (Alan Olan, Journal of Clinical Trials, Vol.13, Issue 4.) which is confirmed by empirical data. This method allows to combine dozens of studies on risk factors together with dozens of studies on biochemistry and physiology to extract implicit information on the causes of non-infectious disease out this entire research.


The use of method requires to find number of causes for a specific non-infectious disease using a special formula and data on disease frequency (usually the incidence rate) in specific population. These disease causes are two or more physiological changes beyond approximately 1-sigma interval which if they are co-existing long enough must trigger the non-infectious disease (triggering is not optional). After that the method requires to find disease causation factors out of multiple risk factors found for the disease. Only some of risk factors are real disease-causing factors. This is achieved using a set of special disease causation criteria discussed in the article by Olan A above and provided here for a reference as well [3]. The method often allows to find few dozen of disease causation factors and more for a non-infectious disease out of existing medical research. These disease causation factors all point to the same set of limited number of physiological parameters changes beyond 1-sigma. The number of these physiological changes usually vary depending on the non-infectious disease from a minimum of 2 to a maximum of 6 or very rare more. In this case the few dozens of disease causation factors make changes (we can say “point”) to the same set of 3 physiological parameters(for example).The method then allows to find these physiological parameter changes (which are the real cause of the non-infectious disease) using a properties based in math. After this the method allows to determine which physiological parameter of these few discovered ones is impacted by each of the dozens of disease causation factors previously found.


Then method allows to group these factors according to the physiological parameter they impact. The disease causation factors taken from each group of these factors and combined together will cause a change beyond 1-sigma to all required for disease triggering physiological parameters. These combinations of disease causation factors applied long enough will cause a non-infectious disease. The occurrence of the disease causation factors is random but once they act together the non-infectious disease triggering is a must unless the factors are removed fast enough. Final step of the method is a validation of its results using other and not used by the method research or with the already discussed disease causation criteria in order to eliminate any errors in steps of the method which a researcher could potentially make. One set of studies is used to get a result. Another independent set is used to verify it.


Once the simultaneously taking place physiological changes causing a non-infectious disease has been found the method allows to build a hypothesis of the disease pathology by using them and “connecting the dots” using the existing medical research on physiology, immunology, etc. The example of this process shown in the work as well. The hypothesis of Celiac disease pathology is proposed as one example of this.

This article introduces to the basics of this method, provides required formulas for calculations and then move to a detailed analysis of Celiac disease. As the method is novel the appendix has an analogy to explain the idea of the method at “high level”. The author’s introduction to the method will allow other medical researchers to use their own and existing research to determine the causes of non-infectious diseases as per presented model, using a simple algorithm.


Results
Using this method and applying multiple existing selected studies at the same time the research analyses Celiac disease and as a result the work gives the causes of Celiac disease as a set of 6 physiological parameters changes beyond 1-sigma interval (slightly less, actually) and also as a set of disease-causing external factors which combinations in an individual must cause Celiac disease as per presented model. The research has found that reduction of Bifidobacterium in the intestine beyond ~1 sigma, reduction of immunoglobulin IgA beyond ~1 sigma (homeostatic IgA), genetic predisposition - HLA-DQ2/ DQ8 common haplotypes (already accepted factor), TNF-alfa increase beyond ~1 sigma along with known factors such as Gluten consumption, and an increased intestinal permeability beyond 1 sigma (a proposed factor) interval will cause the Celiac disease if all conditions coexist long enough (an estimate is within 10-12 months). If all of these physiological changes coexist long enough the disease triggering is not optional it is a must as per the model. The 5 of these physiological parameters (excluding genetic factors) can be changed by different combinations of factors some of which are found in this research.
Because these combination of factors can vary greatly the causation of Celiac disease may look quite complex and random while the real underlying causes - the 6 unique physiological changes stay the same. Some of the discovered in this research external causation factors such as the use of iron supplements at 18 months of age or intake of gluten before 2 years are found to be reducing Bifidobacterium  levels below 1-sigma. Here we observe how 2 different factors are impacting the same physiological change - the Bifidobacterium level and which is only causing the disease if co-exist with 5 other required physiological changes. Another discovered factor such as TNF-α -308 G>A polymorphism (AA+AG vs GG) was creating a TNF-alfa increase beyond 1-sigma in the affected individuals. The external factor such as 3 or more respiratory infections in the first 6 months of child life were also increasing TNF-alfa levels beyond 1-sigma. TNF alfa was increased beyond 1-sigma due to DDE, PFOS, perfluorooctanoic acid pesticides. In other words 3 different factors separately can increase TNF alfa beyond 1-sigma which is a required but not sufficient cause of Celiac disease as the current research showed there should be 6 coexisting physiological changes and TNF alfa beyond 1-sigma cannot cause the Celiac disease as standalone physiological change.
The research rediscover and confirm that HLA-DQ2/DQ8 common haplotypes is a cause of Celiac disease which is consistent with current understanding but at the same time it stresses this is only 1 of 6 causes and cannot cause the disease as standalone factor and this is also consistent with current research on Celiac disease.


This research strongly suggests that the reason we cannot cure the Celiac disease is that it is triggered by 6 coexisting physiological changes and we are only compensating one - by reducing the gluten levels; so because other changes are stay beyond 1-sigma the reintroduction of gluten in the diet satisfies again the coexistence of 6 physiological changes which are required to cause the disease (must haves). The solution would be at least to take care of one or more additional physiological changes (like TNF alfa or homeostatic IgA) which would give a fair chance to cure it and potentially reintroduce gluten in the patient’s diet later. This would allow to have 2 or more disease causing physiological changes (like TNF alfa or homeostatic IgA) out of 6 required to be eliminated and would break the disease-causing physiological set more reliably.


The fact that triggering Celia disease requires a coexistence of 6 physiological changes explains the relatively low (but rising) incidence of 17.4 per 100,000 person per year (in women). The model the current research is based on states that the more incidence rate of non-infectious disease the less number of coexisting physiological changes beyond 1-sigma (actually, slightly less) is required to trigger the disease. This relationship connects epidemiologic data and physiological underlying causes of non-infectious diseases.

Author Biography

  • Alan Olan, Independent Researcher, USA

    Independent Researcher, USA

Downloads

Published

2026-11-12